Christopher Case left his home in Raleigh, North Carolina, to pursue a career in music in Seattle, where he secured a job with AEI. Among his many musical interests was the music of ancient cultures. In April 1991, he took a business trip to San Francisco, where he met a woman to discuss ancient Egyptian music. During their meeting, the woman—whose name remains unknown—made romantic advances toward him. When Case politely refused, the woman became enraged. Claiming to be a witch, she cursed him, vowing he would regret rejecting her. Within a week, Christopher Case was dead.

Upon returning to Seattle, Case was plagued by unsettling dreams and an intense sense of unease, which quickly escalated into terrifying nocturnal encounters. He described these experiences to his friend, Sammye Souder, back in North Carolina, who had some knowledge of the occult. Case reported hearing voices and waking at night pinned to his bed by invisible hands that scratched and beat him. He felt constantly watched and was convinced these entities intended to kill him.
Following Souder’s advice, Case visited religious and occult bookstores in Seattle, searching for answers. He purchased several Bibles, crucifixes, and other religious items in a desperate attempt to protect himself. Despite his efforts, the attacks continued unabated.
On April 16, 1991, when Souder had not heard from Case, she contacted the police and requested a wellness check. Officers visited his apartment but found no one home. As it turned out, Case, terrified of staying in his apartment, had spent the night in a hotel. The next day, Souder received one final, frantic message from him on her answering machine. In the message, Case was panicked and convinced he would not survive the night.
Fearing for his safety, Souder once again called the police. When officers returned to Case’s apartment and received no answer, they entered the residence. Inside, they found him in the bathtub, fully clothed, with his knees drawn to his chest and his head resting against the wall. He was dead.

The state of his apartment raised eyebrows and invited speculation. Lines of salt stretched along the walls, encircling the rooms. Dozens of spent candles littered the living room, and crucifixes and rosaries were placed throughout the home.
The coroner ruled the cause of death as acute myocarditis, a sudden inflammation of the heart muscle. This condition, though rare, can result from viral infections or extreme stress. While some have speculated that Case’s death was caused by psychological distress severe enough to trigger heart failure, such occurrences are exceedingly rare in healthy individuals with no prior medical conditions.
Since the King County Medical Examiner and the Seattle Police Department do not investigate paranormal claims, the official conclusion remains heart failure. However, the eerie circumstances surrounding Christopher Case’s death continue to spark questions about the power of fear, belief, and the unexplained.
Here is the Seattle Times article from May of 1991, if you want to read a bit more.
Jason Roberts is a Seattle-based author noted for his acclaimed western horror series The Dead Wind Trilogy as well as other works of cosmic horror infused with historical fiction. His web-based series, Dark Distractions examines paranormal mysteries, unexplained phenomena, and all things strange.