On this day in 2009, the Jamison family of Eufaula, Oklahoma vanished under mysterious circumstances. A week later, their vehicle was discovered with their cell phones, starving family dog, and $32k in cash. With an abundance of bizarre evidence, wild speculation surrounding the case spawned theories of a  Satanic cult, faked deaths, or a drug deal gone wrong, among others. When their remains were discovered in 2013, only two miles from their abandoned truck, the mystery only deepened.